Shardlake: A Tudor Murder Mystery

Tudor History Gets The Murder Mystery Treatment In Shardlake

Shardlake draws us into an enclosed world of corruption and murder as Henry VIII’s Reformation brings unsettling changes in England, writes John Cooper

“THIS house is rotten to the core,” snarls Jack Barak, Thomas Cromwell’s man of business, as he condemns the Benedictine monastery of St. Donatus to closure and oblivion. Based on Dissolution, the 2003 debut of detective novelist CJ Sansom, Shardlake (a Hulu show) draws us into an enclosed world of corruption and murder as Henry VIII’s Reformation threatens the end of a thousand years of the monastic life in England.

Dissolution is part of the Shardlake series, which totals seven books and has won praise for the believability of its historical settings, as well as the quality of the writing. Originally trained as a historian, Sansom, while not entirely wedded to historical accuracy, brought some of his academic training to his writing. He had the knack of making Tudor England come alive in ways that strictly academic history cannot.

Shardlake begins when a royal commissioner surveying the community of St. Donatus is found beheaded in a crypt. The lawyer Matthew Shardlake, acutely intelligent but underrated on account of a physical disability (he is scornfully written off as a “crookback”), is sent into the monastery to investigate and to secure its closure for Cromwell and his King.

Adapted for screen by Stephen Butchard and directed by Justin Chadwick, the series remains fairly faithful to the book while also bringing a bleak dramatic interpretation of its own. Shardlake's setting is broodingly Gothic. Mist sweeps in from the marshes, torches gutter, black-clad monks glide silently around with their faces hidden. Over four episodes, the body count rises as Shardlake hunts down the evidence that will seal St. Donatus’s fate. He is haunted by the ghost of Mark Smeaton, the young musician whose alleged affair with Henry VIII’s second wife Anne Boleyn sent the Queen to her execution, for reasons that are gradually revealed. An abused novice is befriended by the compassionate Shardlake, but cannot be saved. A monastery pond is dragged for the old evil it contains.

Stream the buzziest new shows with OTTplay Premium's Jhakaas monthly pack, for only Rs 249.

The series is set during the dissolution of the monasteries, which was authorised by the Suppression Acts of 1536 and 1539. Historians still debate why Henry VIII took this revolutionary step: whether any of the rhetoric about re-purposing monastic revenues to charitable use was genuine, or the whole operation was to do with power and money.

Before his infamous divorce from his first wife Katherine of Aragon, King Henry had been a supporter of the religious life and visited monasteries on progress. But when they became associated with resistance to the Reformation, and especially Henry’s stand against the pope, they were fatally compromised.

Reformation historian Peter Marshall argues that the dissolution was a “spectacular, public, evangelical campaign, announcing the purification of the English church”. If King Henry sanctioned that policy, it was Cromwell who imposed and policed it. We see this play out in Sansom’s first book and in Shardlake.

The dissolution of the monasteries was the biggest land grab since the Norman Conquest. The richest pickings went to the crown, leaving the rest to be traded for loyalty to the Reformation and its brokers at the royal court. All sorts of people were involved, from the aristocrats who converted monastic complexes into private houses to the poor who sifted through the gleanings once everyone else was gone.

The English landscape, physical and political, was reshaped by the dissolution in ways that are still being recovered by historians and archaeologists. Although a work of historical fiction, Shardlake reminds us of the mixture of ideology, competition and greed that powered this turning point in history.

All of England’s medieval religious houses were destroyed during the Reformation. This directly impacted the making of Shardlake: the series had to be filmed in Hungary and Romania. So "St. Donatus" is more castle than monastery, complete with watchtowers and secret passageways. It’s not accurate, though the forbidding presence of the building does add to the mood of secrecy and fear.

The show makes for a thrilling watch and the production benefits from strong performances. In the title role, Arthur Hughes is watchful and softly-spoken but capable of showing steel when provoked. Hughes himself has radial dysplasia and brilliantly evokes Sansom’s detective. Anthony Boyle is excellent as Barak, his swagger and quick temper complementing Shardlake’s subtler methods. Meanwhile, Sean Bean is a menacing and amoral Cromwell.

Christopher Sansom died just days before Shardlake was first screened. As joint executive producer, he gave his blessing to the production. With several other excellent Shardlake novels to call on, it seems likely there will be more seasons to come.

This review originally appeared on The Conversation and has been republished under the Creative Commons Licence. John Cooper is a reader in History at the University of York.

Here's where you can watch Hulu's Shardlake in India

Like what you read? Get more of what you like. Visit the OTTplay website, or download the app to stay up-to-date with news, recommendations and special offers on streaming content.

Plus: always get the latest reviews. Sign up for our newsletters.

OUR OTHER NEWSLETTERS

This weekly newsletter compiles a list of the latest (and most important) reviews from OTTplay so you can figure what to watch or ditch over the weekend ahead.

Each week, our editors pick one long-form, writerly piece that they think it worthy of your attention, and dice it into easily digestible bits for you to mull over.

In which we invite a scholar of cinema, devotee of the moving image, to write a prose poem dedicated to their poison of choice. Expect to spend an
hour on this.