In My Opinion - The liberal test, a disunited Pakistani army & Hajj scams

ThePrint Opinion Mailer
ThePrint

Saturday 13 May 2023

In My Opinion

 

By Rama Lakshmi, Editor, Opinion & Ground Reports

 
 

The politics of boycotts and bans are back. Whether it is Pathan or Kashmir Files, the conversation is so divisive that it often tests classical Indian liberalism and shows it up as hollow.

Now, cinema halls in West Bengal and Tamil Nadu are not showing The Kerala Story. And Uttar Pradesh is making it tax-free viewing. The movie is dismissed as alarmist propaganda by some and hailed as brave truth-telling by others. Vir Sanghvi wrote in a provocative and important essay that people such as Shashi Tharoor and Shabana Azmi have come out strongly against the ban even as they disapprove of the film. But there is a growing backlash against the liberal let-the-people-decide point of view. Are liberals letting a secular, pluralistic and diverse India down by supporting those who spread communal poison?

Ibn Khaldun Bharti argued the liberal-secular patrons of the Islamic preachers neither talk about conversions nor let others do the talking.

Pakistan is imploding. Politics is broken, and the all-powerful army doesn’t appear to be united. Ayesha Siddiqa wrote that no leader created by the politically influential Pakistan Army has ever dug his heels and fought back this hard, especially in his early years of power. And the army chief needs to settle the difference with his Generals.

Praveen Swami wrote that Imran Khan might seem an unlikely icon for an explosion of proletarian rage: He is, after all, alleged to have helped himself to expensive gifts as well as state lands, and cultivated cronies one of whom flashes $100,000 handbags. But the fact is that for the first time in Pakistan’s history, action against a political leader has inspired an impromptu mini-intifada against the military itself.

After the Supreme Court verdict on the powers of Delhi government, Akshay Marathe wrote that the dispute between AAP and the Modi government is neither legal nor political or ideological. It was borne out of the BJP's inability to accept defeat. An environment secretary of the Delhi government skipped 20 meetings called by the environment minister to review preparedness for the pollution season.

The Ground Reports team fanned out across the country and brought stories about Blinkit delivery workers’ woes from Ghaziabad and online gambling addiction from Bengaluru.

The ambitious reform of transferring Army cantonment land to civil municipal authorities has begun. And the first city this is being implemented is Yol in Himachal Pradesh. Cantonments have existed in India for over two centuries, with the first being set up in Barrackpore in 1765 by the East-India Company. Suchet Vir Singh wrote that the Khas Yol cantonment board has now officially ceased to function. Files are being burned and furniture moved out. And citizens are anxious and excited about the big change.

The new Hajj season’s first flight from India is set to take off on 21 May. Saudi Arabia allotted a huge hajj quota of 1,75,025 to India this year, up from 79,237 last year. But there has been a worrying surge in Hajj scams and fake agents duping unsuspecting small town Muslims, reported Heena Fatima.

From domestic abuse to hospital expenses to neighbourhood troubles, the Gorakhnath Mutt has a solution for everything. The people of UP may not be able to easily reach CM Yogi Adityanath in Lucknow with their grievances, but the ancient mutt has emerged as the ante-room to the seat of power. They mete out solutions and dole advice, forward requests to Lucknow, bring in the city sub-divisional magistrate to check local problems and sometimes, even find a groom, reported Sagrika Kissu.

 

Tharoors and Shabana Azmis took a classic liberal stand on ‘Kerala Story’. They must rethink

I do think we should debate how to respond when popular culture is used to divide the Indian people. India is changing. Perhaps our responses should change too. Read more...

By Vir Sanghvi

 

The Kerala Story—It’s time Muslims give up their medieval ideal of conquest, conversion

The liberal-secular patrons of the Islamic preachers neither talk about conversions nor let others do the talking. They are devoid of integrity and lack tools to analyse the phenomenon. Read more...

By Ibn Khaldun Bharati

 

Imran Khan’s arrest in Pakistan proof the Army has won. But silencing him won’t help govt

The Al-Qadir Trust case is just the beginning of the military’s plan to lock up Imran until he surrenders. Read more...

By Ayesha Siddiqa

 

More than Imran, it’s jihadist influence on Pakistan army that’s Gen Asim Munir’s headache

For the first time in Pakistan’s history, action against a political leader has inspired an impromptu mini-intifada against the military itself. Read more...

By Praveen Swami

BJP started a pointless battle in Delhi, officers followed. Supreme Court verdict first step

The dispute between AAP and the Modi government is neither legal nor political or ideological. It was borne out of the BJP's inability to accept defeat. Read more...

By Akshay Marathe

 

At Yol, it’s not just a cantonment being dismantled. A town is getting divided

A unique and intricate civil-military confluence has developed in the cantonments. This, experts point out, could create complications for the abolishment process. Read more...

By Suchet Vir Singh

 

Hajj frauds, umrah scams are trapping Indian Muslims. Pay and get ghosted

For victims, the pitfalls on the road to Mecca can lead to bankruptcy and shattered dreams. In a few cases, even rich & educated Muslims have fallen for these scams. Read more...

By Heena Fatima

 

Yogi Maharaj’s Gorakhpur darbar is a one-stop solution for everything — grooms and goons

It takes two people to do Yogi’s job at the darbar in his absence. Temple manager Dwarka Tiwari and retired SDM Vinod Kumar Thakur. Read more...

By Sagrika Kissu

 
Support ThePrint's Journalism

Read more of ThePrintOpinion here.

You are receiving this because you are a reader of ThePrint and posted a comment or signed up to receive this newsletter. We appreciate your feedback.

Follow ThePrint


Previous Post Next Post

Contact Form